It’s such a simple concept that talent acquisition professionals in long term care sometimes take it for granted – you should hire nice people to work at your communities. My friend/AP Journalist Katie Zeizma travels a lot for her job. She was in the lobby bar at some hotel somewhere in the United States and saw a sign that said “Now Hiring: Nice People.” That seems like a no-brainer for any hospitality position, which make it kind of funny to see the sign. I know you probably wouldn’t post a big sign at your community’s front desk or on your career website that says, “Now Hiring: Nice People.” You need to hire a person with the right technical skills, which means evaluating “niceness” isn’t necessarily part of the hiring equation. However, while the term “nice” might be too simplistic, at the end of the day you do need employees who are going to treat your residents nicely to ensure resident and family satisfaction. In long term care, being a “nice person” means having compassion, flexibility, a strong work ethic, openness to learning, and so much more. But how do you evaluate the “nice” factor?
Consider Candidate Adaptability
“Adaptability” isn’t a synonym for “nice.” But due to the resident-centered care movement, individualized care is becoming increasingly important, and that kind of care requires adaptability. I recently spoke with Melissa Koehn, Human Resources Director at Newton Presbyterian Manor, about their hiring process. Presbyterian Manor has 18 communities in Kansas and Missouri, and Newton Presbyterian is the first community they established. The community has 130 employees, and in any given month, they have between four and five open positions; these are frequently part-time opportunities. “We want people who don’t just ‘talk the talk’ but who actually ‘walk the walk.’ Just because you get certified to be a CNA doesn’t mean you’re a good CNA for us,” said Koehn. “When we’re interviewing people, we want to evaluate their soft skills, too.” One of the most important traits Newton Presbyterian evaluates is adaptability. “We’re really looking for people who can change on the fly, who can adapt to different residents, because every person is different,” noted Koehn. But this doesn’t just apply to direct caregivers; nearly every employee in every department touches the lives of the residents. Adaptability includes how all of the staff communicates with the residents. “We are looking for people who are very flexible with addressing the same needs for different residents. Many of the resident requests and concerns might be the same, but because everyone’s different those needs are expressed differently.”
Evaluating Soft Skills
So how does Newton Presbyterian evaluate soft skills, like adaptability? They start off by considering how the candidate approaches the application. “The application says a lot to me – how a person fills it out,” said Koehn. “Are they sending me to dig for information in their resume? Or are they putting everything I’ve asked for on the application.” Koehn also considers the completeness of the application and the depth of information provided, in terms of their previous work experience. Those candidates who do well on the application, and have the necessary technical skills and background for the role, are then invited to complete a behavioral assessment online. “It’s not a pass/fail kind of test,” Koehn clarified. “It gives us an overview of whether they might be a good cultural fit for our community.” At Newton Presbyterian, they explain to the candidate the purpose of the behavioral assessment before the candidate takes the online survey at home or onsite at the community. Explaining the assessment helps ensure the candidate is comfortable with the process. Then they let the assessment do its job. One of the best features is that the assessment hones in on critical areas, such as compassion, by asking the same questions in different ways. “This will illicit some really good information about that candidate,” noted Koehn. “Something I really appreciate about the assessment is that it gives you a different way of asking a question to get the behavioral information you need. You can evaluate how candidates answer the survey, and this gives you a more well-rounded view of that person.”
A More Thoughtful Process
Typically, the next step in the application process, for those candidates that Koehn and the hiring manager would like to move forward with, is an in-person interview. This is a good chance for the potential new hire to learn more about the Newton Presbyterian’s employment policies, the role they would be taking on, and the culture at the organization. When it comes to in-person interviews, honesty is the best policy. According to Koehn: “Our honesty with people about exactly what we’re looking for helps them relax during the interview and know that we’re going to share the truth with them no matter what.” Thanks to creating a more structured interview process and being more mindful of the soft skills that are necessary for employees to have before joining their community, Newton Presbyterian is now, “working harder for the right candidate and not just a good candidate.” Koehn said the initial resistance to implementing behavioral assessment software has faded because hiring managers realize they are truly measuring what matters in their candidates. “People who wear their heart on their sleeve; people who give service from the heart ─ that’s who we’re looking for.”
Enter to Win an iPad! Watch this short product tour by 5/31 to learn how HealthcareSource’s Staff Assessment can help you hire compassionate caregivers and you’ll be entered to win an iPad!
Dear Rebecca,
I loved the article. I have been preaching and trying to create a “Culture of Nice” It is such a simple and important concept, but so many just don’t seem to get it. I have often said to managers that “You get what you tolerate.” And you do.
It is so important to make smart hires. You can have someone with all the qualifications and training to do a job, but you simply can’t teach compassion, politeness, and teamwork to someone that is not interested in it. In the end, we have a much better environment for our Residents and for those of us that work together as well!
“Nice” job.
Theodore Barss
Thank you Theodore, I’m so glad you enjoyed my post!
Via Email
Steve…for what it’s worth….a little tongue in cheek, but it’s what we do:
We hire “nice” people, though we call it hiring for “Glitter and Glow”. Glitter and Glow is a “manifestation of the nurturing gene”. A person can’t be taught to be nice, or be a nurturer, it’s inherent. They have or they don’t, they are or they aren’t. The “nurturing gene” is passed on from parents or Grandpa and grandma. Service skills on the other hand can be taught.
So we hire the person for their Glitter and Glow and teach them the job.
One caveat: we might find an LPN candidate that is the nicest person in the world, but if they don’t have the license, not much we can do. We might have a Sous Chef candidate be the nicest person in the world, but if they have never seen the inside of a kitchen, not much we can do….so this said, hiring for Glitter and Glow is largely for non management positions though the management needs to possess Glitter and Glow too.
We seek the nurturing gene in how we interview.
Starting with a group interview that we do 2 times per month for all positions. Several managers are always in attendance and I keep notes.
First question: Compare yourself to a cartoon character or a fictional character and tell us why you relate to them. (the manager participate in the question too. I’m Bart Simpson, but won’t go there right now…) Second question: Tell us about a time that you made an impact on a person’s life and include how your character contributed to this.
Through these two questions we evaluate the believability of the story of impacting a person’s life and if the character relation supports what they say. The managers stay after the group interview and do the evaluations right then.
Those that can’t or don’t have answers for the questions are not considered for employment. Those that are being considered move on to “individual” interviews at a later date that also have several facilitators.
We do check references and background, so the hiring process isn’t completely altruistic.
We must be doing something right….In an industry fraught with 100%+ turnover, ours is less than 60%.
Statistically, there seems to be something to be said about hiring Nice People!
Now, we’re trying to figure out how to hire gregarious people like Bill Shorten, one of the founders/partners you met!
Dave Schneck, Executive Director
Cascades of the Sierra, Sparks Nevada
From LinkedIn Groups
Excellent point made……… but, a niceness barometer would help.
By Anne L. Duggan
From LinkedIn Groups
Yes! When I am hiring caregivers, I look for heart. I figure that the rest is teachable, but kindness and caring are not.
By Cynthia Robinson Bove
From LinkedIn Groups
Asking people to give you concrete examples of a situation where they went the extra mile, stepped out of the box, etc. can really deliver a reality check on whether they are truly a nice person or not. They all know the answers that you want to hear. Asking for a real life story will either throw them off or you will hear something that will tear at your heart strings and then you will know.
By Debbie Vermillion
From LinkedIn Groups
Also if the candidate has been unemployed for a while, ask what the candidate has been doing to grow his or her professional skills in the interim. How the person response can reveal the how the person perceives employment — as just a job versus a profession, a calling, an opportunity to develop interests and new skills, etc. Niceness, work ethic, and perceiving work as an opportunity to pursue fulfillment are all important.
By Martin “Marty” Womer
From LinkedIn Groups
I only hire new employees if they were on vacation in “Nice”. Any health care employer hires for (1) qualifications; (2) experience; (3) education: (4) interview presentation; and a few other extraneous factors. If the position is for a caregiver, you look for compassion (the word “nice” is entirely too boring) and attitude.
By Howard Pearl
From LinkedIn Groups
Nice people are hiring me. : o) .
By Evan B. Gessman
From LinkedIn Groups
Niceness rules!!!
By Heather Sinclair
From LinkedIn Groups
Niceness to often thought of in business as a weakness instead of a strength. Can’t say we should buy in to that line of thinking.
By Scudder, Richard
From LinkedIn Groups
Perhaps kindness would be better suited?? Just be kind!
By Heather Sinclair
From LinkedIn Groups
I feel like I’ m too nice to even share my concern I will call this my weakness
By Uzma Qureshi
From LinkedIn Groups
Empathy, compassion, putting others first, forgivness, fair, and of course NICENESS. Wouldn’t that make for a great boss?
By Derek Keith Tilley
From LinkedIn Groups
There is nothing like seeing the person in action with a client to evaluate their motivation for working in this field.
By Susan Mojaverian, MSN, RN
From LinkedIn Groups
If I can help it, in Hospice care, Niceness is one of the most important qualities you can find, most other things can be taught.
By Susan Curry
From LinkedIn Groups
I agree with you, Susan. Other things can be taught. I have seen caregivers with the best work ethic, works hard, dependable,etc, but one on one resident caring is missing. The nurturing, caring about the resident’s as individuals are missing. I want my staff to care about “my” residents as much as I do. To go out of their way to make them smile, to engage them, to hug them. These are inherent traits that can’t be taught.
By Gina Conte
From LinkedIN Groups
But, let it be known I am ALL about the Senior, or those who may be in need, and if I see Elderly Abuse, you better be ready to go THRU me because it will ot happen…if I am there. I have seen and hired a girl to help me on a job(4days later)she told me the husband of the client was “verbally abusing her” truth is she was Verbally abusing him! She diagnoised his wife for him….cross my bounderies!if he had wanted to know he should have ask her Dr…she (caregiver) told me “She was getting even” I say to you, do you think she had a smile on her face when she told him this..I bet she did! .and when she told me that she was going to send broshears with no return address about congestive Heart failure? This is what I said to her: XXXX(name) ..his has went way to far…you are there to care for her, not to diagnois,! You do not send broshears to get even! as she had told me Then I said and if you do…I will see A. Interseed! & B. C 2 you neer get another job in NW AR! 3 FIRED! Do you know he broke a hip and she went an interviewed with him again> He ask her don’t I know you? No Sir…
Do you know Carol Carter? No Sir…the great thing …..was the administrator of facility was there..called me, and I told her HE WAS RIGHT, and I told her I can’t belive this! She ask my permission to call the place she was so highly recommeded from..I said absolutely…they called me and said well, we have never had any other complaints..I said well, maybe she puts on Happy face and pretends to be “NICE” and all I can tell you is what I know….in this profession if you cannot put yourself above the situation and take control and work it out in the best interest of the client..simple…resign.then find a new job that you may be more suited for:)
By Carol Carter
From LinkedIn Groups
@ Susan Curry…@Gina Conte…
I love these comments of yours. I enjoy making people smile and while we are dealing with contagious things on a regular basis that we try to avoid for fear of spreading to patients, the one contagious thing that we really should try and spread is a smile plumb full with sincere kindness! Smile at almost any person from 3 feet away…It is usually returned in kind.
By Justin Roach
From LinkedIn Groups
Justin, I agree with your comments also. I noticed you are a Maintenance Director. The sweetest things I have noticed have come from our Maintenance Director and our painter. They stop and talk to the residents. They take them to their rooms if no one is around. Our MD dresses up as the Bunny Rabbit on Easter and hands out candy and hugs to the kids and the residents! We have a resident in the dementia unit who gets very agitated, our painter always could calm him down and walk him back to his room. These are the kind of people I would hire if I were in the position to have my own facility.
By Gina Conte
From LinkedIn Groups
Hiring ‘nice people’ is about hiring the right people that are also caring AND compassionate. Soft skills are an important factor in determining if a caregiver is right for LivHOME. Soft skills go hand in hand with great communication skills and those are critical in the caregiving process. We want caregivers that think on their feet and and are able to develop personal relationships with the patient and their family. LivHOME has a very strict and efficient process for selecting caregivers. First off, before we match a new Caregiver with a client, we will have a geriatric Care Manager meet with the client and family and assesses all their needs. The LivHOME Care Manager will match the appropriate Caregiver (based on needs, skills, and personality) to the client. We take every precaution to match the right Caregiver with the client’s needs. To become a LivHOME Caregiver, you must have the necessary Skills (provide assistance with Activities of Daily Living), Experience (minimum 1 year experience caring for an older adult), credible work references, strong background, and impeccable communication skills. Communication is the key in our hiring process, we want Caregivers who will go above and beyond to provide the excellent care our patients deserve.
http://www.LivHOME.com
By Colby Ravetto